im looking to travel to the caribbean in the middle of september but cant make my mind up in what part to go?

st lucia

mm

Go to Bahamas

NOT JAMAICA.
anyone whos been lately can agree it's got the appeal of a third world country

try the Bermuda Triangle, you never know where you'll end up!

It depends on what you like. I would suggest Puerto Rico, St. Lucia or St. Maarten. They each are friendly, have lots to do, great restaurants and nightlife. Puerto Rico and St. Maarten also have great shopping.

barbados

US Virgin Islands was my best experience so far.

That's prime hurricane season, so you may want to consider travel insurance for your trip. The ABC islands [Aruba, Bonaire and Curacao] are less-prone to hurricanes than the other islands.